[Many thanks to Vanessa Lynn for bringing this item to our attention. And thanks to Myriam J.A. Chancy for sharing an earlier article, « Il y a 196 ans, la ‘dette de l’indépendance’: La rançon de la liberté du genre humain et de l’indépendance nationale », by historian Gusti-Klara Gaillard (Le Nouvelliste, 2021)] This article by Catherine Porter, Constant Méheut, Matt Apuzzo, and Selam Gebrekidan (The New York Times) brings to the general public the topics of many discussions and writings by historians, sociologists, literary and social critics, philosophers, and other scholars in their arguments in favor of reparations. Here are a few excerpts:
Coffee has been the fulcrum of life here for almost three centuries, since enslaved people cut the first French coffee plantations into the mountainsides. Back then, this was not Haiti, but Saint-Domingue — the biggest supplier of coffee and sugar consumed in Parisian kitchens and Hamburg coffee houses. The colony made many French families fabulously rich. It was also, many historians say, the world’s most brutal.
Ms. Present’s ancestors put an end to that, taking part in the modern world’s first successful slave revolution in 1791 and establishing an independent nation in 1804 — decades before Britain outlawed slavery or the Civil War broke out in America.
But for generations after independence, Haitians were forced to pay the descendants of their former slave masters, including the Empress of Brazil; the son-in-law of the Russian Emperor Nicholas I; Germany’s last imperial chancellor; and Gaston de Galliffet, the French general known as the “butcher of the Commune” for crushing an insurrection in Paris in 1871.
The burdens continued well into the 20th century. The wealth Ms. Present’s ancestors coaxed from the ground brought wild profits for a French bank that helped finance the Eiffel Tower, Crédit Industriel et Commercial, and its investors. They controlled Haiti’s treasury from Paris for decades, and the bank eventually became part of one of Europe’s largest financial conglomerates.
Haiti’s riches lured Wall Street, too, delivering big margins for the institution that ultimately became Citigroup. It elbowed out the French and helped spur the American invasion of Haiti — one of the longest military occupations in United States history. [. . .]
Violence. Tragedy. Hunger. Underdevelopment. These bywords have clung to Haiti for more than a century. Kidnappings. Outbreaks. Earthquakes. The president assassinated — this time in his bedroom.
How is it possible, many ask, that Haiti shares an island with the Dominican Republic, with its underground subway system, health care coverage, public schools, teeming resorts and impressive stretches of economic growth? [. . .]
But another story is rarely taught or acknowledged: The first people in the modern world to free themselves from slavery and create their own nation were forced to pay for their freedom yet again — in cash. [. . .]
No country could be expected to come to Haiti’s defense. The world powers had frozen it out, refusing to officially acknowledge its independence. American lawmakers in particular did not want enslaved people in their own country to be inspired by Haiti’s self-liberation and rise up. [. . .]
So, Haiti’s president, eager for the trade and security of international recognition, bowed to France’s demands. With that, Haiti set another precedent: It became the world’s first and only country where the descendants of enslaved people paid reparations to the descendants of their masters — for generations.
It is often called the “independence debt.” But that is a misnomer. It was a ransom.
The amount was far beyond Haiti’s meager means. Even the first installment was about six times the government’s income that year, based on official receipts documented by the 19th-century Haitian historian Beaubrun Ardouin.
But that was the point, and part of the plan. The French king had given the baron a second mission: to ensure the former colony took out a loan from young French banks to make the payments.
This became known as Haiti’s “double debt” — the ransom and the loan to pay it — a stunning load that boosted the fledgling Parisian international banking system and helped cement Haiti’s path into poverty and underdevelopment. According to Ardouin’s records, the bankers’ commissions alone exceeded the Haitian government’s total revenues that year.
And that was only the beginning. The double debt helped push Haiti into a cycle of debts that hobbled the country for more than 100 years, draining away much of its revenue and chopping away at its ability to build the essential institutions and infrastructure of an independent nation. Generations after enslaved people rebelled and created the first free Black nation in the Americas, their children were forced to work, sometimes for little or even no pay, for the benefit of others — first the French, then the Americans, then their own dictators. [. . .]
For full article and illustrations, see https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/20/world/americas/haiti-history-colonized-france.html
Also see 2021 article (in French) by historian Gusti-Klara Gaillard at https://lenouvelliste.com/article/230931/il-y-a-196-ans-la-dette-de-lindependance
3 thoughts on “The Ransom/The Root of Haiti’s Misery: Reparations to Enslavers”
JUSTICE FOR HAITI,
It’s with this word that we are filing an international lawsuit before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in Hague over the assassination of the Haitian President on July 7, 2021 done by a group of 26 heavily-armed terrorists. For proper investigation we are putting under arrest the President’s Cabinet, Presidential Security, opposition leaders. We demand the removal of immunity of all foreign presidents, diplomats involved in this conspiracy to be on trial before the International Court of Justice, because Haiti is a victim of terrorism and an international plot organized by countries of the UN and the EU. We demand an investigation on Immigration Control Agents who let those terrorists get in our country to commit this state crime by assassinating the President which is an act of war. We are taking legal action against these countries involved in this international hate crime against Haiti through the international court of justice in Hague and remove immediately embassies in our country who are real threats to national security of Haiti such as espionage, terrorism that led to the assassination of the president. We urge the International Criminal Court (ICC) to issue global arrest warrant for those criminals, and one year has already passed but until now no follow up has been made public. So, Please help us to get JUSTICE FOR HAITI THROUGH THE INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE IN HAGUE.