Review: ‘Another Brooklyn’ Renders Beauty Amidst Tragedy


A review by Lesley-Ann Brown of Another Brooklyn by Jacqueline Woodson


For God so loved the world, their father would say, he gave his only begotten son. But what about the daughters, I wondered? What did God do with his daughters?

-Another Brooklyn

When I began reading Jacqueline Woodson’s novel, “Another Brooklyn,” I could not put it down.

Not only could I not put it down, but when I did finish it I found myself longing to pick it up again and live through what I could only describe as a love letter to a Brooklyn gone—both for the characters in the book and for all those for whom Brooklyn seemed to offer a glimmer of hope, albeit fleeting for some, to a dignified life.

Woodson expertly weaves together themes of death, friendship, Black migrations, the sense of displacement that usually follows, and family. (She just made the longlist for the National Book Award for fiction, which celebrates the best of the best in American literature from the past year.)

Through the careful placing of various traditional rituals of death it reminds me of the genre of the music mentioned from the very beginning: Jazz. “If we had jazz, would we have survived differently?” the narrator, August wonders.

When a return home to bury her father leads to an unexpected encounter with a friend from the past on a train ride in Brooklyn, memory becomes telling in so many ways.

Because Bushwick had once been a forest and we had been called ghetto girls even though we were beautiful and our arms were locked together and our t-shirts blared our names and zodiac signs.

The story, playing like Coltrane or Miles, captures the lives of four friends: Sylvia, Angela, Gigi and the main character August. The story gets under appearances and reveals the pain, the cracks, of what it meant to be a Black girl growing up in Brooklyn.

With references from Igbo Landing to Black land ownership—this is a story that not only should be widely read, but studied. Not least of all for its literary merit.

“Another Brooklyn” is immaculate prose. It captures a time when whites were running out of Brooklyn, while many of us from the South and the Caribbean settled there for better opportunities we were told were to be had.

There was a time in the ’70s when Blackness ripened, perfected, was about to burst – and then came the ’80s along with President Reagan.

“Another Brooklyn” is set somewhere between this time – of migrations from the South to the Summer of Sam and the violence of women it symbolized—as a mirror crafted with words which reflect why so many theorize that “Brooklyn” may actually in fact have come from a Dutch word meaning “Broken Land.”

“Another Brooklyn” is not just a novel. It is an example of what happens when a writer commits herself to rendering beauty even in the midst of tragedy. This is Woodson’s first adult novel in twenty years. I can only hope that she gives us more.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s