Puerto Rico Referendum: Will the Island Vote to Reduce Constitutional Rights?

Associated Press explains the situation clearly in “Puerto Rico votes on plan to amend constitution.” The vote is going on today, August 19, 2012.

Puerto Rico is holding a two-part referendum on Sunday that could see the island amend its constitution for the first time in nearly half a century. The referendum would reduce the size of the U.S. territory’s government by almost 30 percent as a cost-cutting measure, and would give judges the right to deny bail in certain murder cases. Puerto Rico currently is the only place in the Western hemisphere where all suspects, including those charged with rape and murder, are entitled to bail.

Supporters say the proposals would save the government money, reduce crime and protect witnesses and the relatives of victims. Opponents say the measures would give more power to remaining legislators and strip suspects of their constitutional rights.

Puerto Rico reported a record number of homicides last year and is struggling to quell a wave of drug-related violence that has killed an increasing number of innocent bystanders. Puerto Ricans also have expressed anger over legislative spending and political corruption scandals that have forced the resignation of several officials.

Senate President Thomas Rivera Schatz urged voters to approve both proposals, saying the money saved from shrinking the legislature would be used to fight crime and improve the island’s education system. The referendum calls for reducing the number of Senate seats from 27 to 17 and the number of House seats from 51 to 39. Rivera also reminded voters of several high-profile cases in which murder suspects who posted bail were accused of killing again. Among those was Xavier Jimenez Bencevi, who was out on bail in 2007 when he was accused of killing a federal witness and of trying to kill two police officers. “We have to stop people like that in their tracks,” Rivera said. “We have to treat them differently. ”

[. . .] If approved, judges would have the discretion to deny bail to those accused of premeditated murder, of killing a police officer or of killing someone in a public space or during a home invasion, sexual assault or drive-by shooting. As in the U.S., prosecutors would have to prove the suspect is a flight risk or a danger to the community.

But the bail proposal has been criticized by many, including Jose Andreu Garcia, former chief justice of Puerto Rico’s Supreme Court. He said limiting bail would not reduce crime and argued the proposal  “is intended to shift attention from the real factors that lead to rampant and unresolved crimes,” such as poor crime investigations and improperly trained police and prosecutors.

[. . .] Puerto Rico’s constitution currently prohibits judges from denying bail or setting an excessively high bail, a determination left up to the court’s interpretation. Defense attorneys also can ask that a different judge lower bail. If the referendum is approved, the bail amendment would go into effect almost immediately, while the reduction of the legislature would become effective January 2017.

For full article in English, see http://www.boston.com/news/world/caribbean/2012/08/18/puerto-rico-votes-plan-amend-constitution/yGmmEa2R9OeFFdzxklFpvO/story.html; in Spanish, see http://www.elnuevodia.com/portavozdeorganizacionpuertoricoparatod@spidevotarno-1324838.html

Photo “Behind Bars/ Atrás Das Grades” by Carla and Bruno Sá: http://www.flickr.com/photos/carla_e_bruno/463864622/

One thought on “Puerto Rico Referendum: Will the Island Vote to Reduce Constitutional Rights?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s